“grab the nightmare, look it straight in the eye”
I'm Not Gay : A Musical
1.0
2 votes·2023
·1h 41m
·MovieDramaMusic
Overview
Plagued by a hidden childhood trauma that is destroying his life, an obsessive-compulsive MMA fighter moves to Fire Island and pretends to be gay in order to buy the house of his dreams and exorcise his demons.
Keywords
identity crisismusicalmixed martial arts (mma)obsessive compulsive disorder (ocd)lgbtfire islandtraumatic childhoodself-harmpretending to be gaypersonal demons
Cast
Sydney James Harcourt
Misha
Alan Mingo Jr.
Maxi
Brad Bradley
Rush
George Dvorsky
Mr. Osborne
Griffin Santopietro
Carey
You Might Also Like
Based on this title
8.4
Fight Club
1999·Drama, Thriller
6.7
Springsteen: Deliver Me from Nowhere
2025·Drama, Music
7.0
Whitney Houston: I Wanna Dance with Somebody
2022·Music, History
6.4
The Smashing Machine
2025·Drama, History
8.3
The Punisher: One Last Kill
2026·Action, Drama
7.7
The Normal Heart
2014·Drama
7.0
Boy Erased
2018·Drama
6.9
Velvet Goldmine
1998·Drama, Music
7.6
Better Man
2024·Music, Drama
6.4
Too Late Blues
1961·Drama, Music
Similar Titles
More like I'm Not Gay : A Musical
1.8
I Would Like to Tell You
2017·Fantasy, Drama
LIEB MICH! - Latin Gay Shorts Volume 5
2017·Romance, Drama
4.0
Baka Sakali
2023·Drama, Romance
Every Time I See A Yellow Car
2026·Thriller, Drama
7.5
Morning Star
1980·Drama
6.6
The Pirates of Penzance
1980·Music, Comedy
5.5
Happy Go Lucky
1943·Comedy, Music
7.0
Homesick for You
1952·Music, Drama
7.0
Tell Me How
2018·Drama, Romance
7.0
Tevye and His Seven Daughters
1968·Drama