Cast
Tom Everett Scott
Joe Matthews / Micah Matthias
Sarah Lancaster
Rachel Troyler
Thomas Kapanowski
Bobby Matthews / Bobby Matthias
Kelly McGillis
Bertha Troyler
Nicole Badaan
Kim
Annie Kitral
Lydia Troyler
Katherine DeBoer
Chloe Styles
Marianna Alacchi
Anna Troyler
Ken Strunk
Eli Troyler
Greg Violand
Ed Spencer
John Eby
Sam Phillips
Geoffrey Hoffman
Dylan Matthias
Kaitlyn Sapp
Elise
Chris Van Vliet
Reporter #1
Jeannie Madison
Reporter #2
You Might Also Like
Based on this title
6.3
TalhotBlond
2012·Drama, TV Movie
6.8
Site Unseen: An Emma Fielding Mystery
2017·Mystery, TV Movie
6.2
Love Finds You in Charm
2015·TV Movie, Drama
7.2
Anne of Green Gables
2016·Drama, Family
6.5
Starving in Suburbia
2014·Drama, TV Movie
6.5
Kept Woman
2015·Thriller, TV Movie
6.3
My Dinner with Hervé
2018·Drama, TV Movie
6.3
A Wrinkle in Time
2003·Drama, Sci-Fi
6.3
Inherit the Wind
1999·Drama, TV Movie
Similar Titles
More like Love Finds You In Sugarcreek
7.1
Key to Love
2023·TV Movie, Comedy
6.8
Sand Dollar Cove
2021·TV Movie, Comedy
6.3
The Baker's Son
2021·TV Movie, Romance
7.3
Love at the Lodge
2023·TV Movie, Comedy
6.4
Vote One for Love
2023·TV Movie, Comedy
6.5
Campfire Kiss
2017·Comedy, Romance
5.8
Love's Last Resort
2017·Drama, Romance
6.7
Expecting Amish
2014·TV Movie, Drama
5.6
Looking for Mr. Right
2014·Romance, Comedy
6.4
Inspiring Love
2023·TV Movie, Comedy
Brimstone, the Amish Horse
1968·Adventure, Drama
6.9
The Shell Seekers
2007·Drama, Romance